29 Comments
User's avatar
UBERSOY's avatar

She is just making excuses for her perverted friends. Nothing more.

Zero Contradictions's avatar

Serious Question: Why should consensual pedophilic acts be illegal?

Do you have any rational arguments that aren't already addressed by this essay? https://zerocontradictions.net/misc/lanzas-pedophilia-essay

Leon Voß's avatar

- homosexuality should be illegal which implies molesting little boys should be illegal

- girls should have a hymen when married, if they don't the pair bonding is probably messed up. Pregnancy doesn't work or is dangerous before they're done with puberty. Therefore having sex with little girls should be illegal

FWIW, libtards can't justify their opposition to pedophila, their arguments come down to making shit up about mental trauma and emotions while ignoring tons of contradictions in their tolerance to LGBT and premarital sex.

Zero Contradictions's avatar

Why should homosexuality be illegal? Do you have a rational justification? I agree that homosexuality and pedophilia should *not* be normalized, since they are unnatural (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ucn2KzCDnOY). I don't support normalizing hard drugs, gambling, or prostitution either, but I don't see any good reasons to outlaw them. https://zerocontradictions.net/civilization/political-philosophy#drug-war

I don't think there's enough evidence to prove that it messes up pair bonding. Regardless, it makes more sense to educate children about the potential harms of sex, rather than to censor it completely from them, as addressed in the essay (https://zerocontradictions.net/misc/lanzas-pedophilia-essay#uninformed-dangers). The main reason why pair bonding is messed up these days is because the state is able to provide for women these days. https://zerocontradictions.net/pdfs/modern-romance.pdf Plenty of people have sex before marriage before having successful marriages these days.

Also, 95% of consensual pedophilic relationships don't involve penetration, nor do most pedophiles encourage penetration with pre-puberty children. https://zerocontradictions.net/misc/lanzas-pedophilia-essay#STDs

I agree that most leftists (and most people in general) don't have any proper justifications against pedophilia.

Alex Hume's avatar

Damn, which friends are these? I'm genuinely curious now.

Friedrich Gerhard's avatar

This paper goes over the data from Denmark as well as the other countries mentioned and the claims contained therein. It found that violent sexual assault and rape actually increased when porn proliferated as many other sexual crimes such as voyeurism, "peeping," incest, and others were simultaneously decriminalized, which incorrectly demonstrated an overall drop in sex crimes over that period.

It also studies the effects of Sexually Oriented Businesses (SOBs) in a couple of major cities and found:

♦ Austin, TX -- 1986 - in four study areas with SOBs, sexually related crimes were 177%

to 482% higher than the city's average.

♦ Indianapolis, IN -- 1984-1986 - Between 1978-1982, crime in study areas was 46%

higher than for the city as a whole. Sex related crimes were four times greater when

SOBs were located near residential areas vs. commercial areas.

♦ Garden Grove, CA -- 1981-1990 - On Garden Grove Blvd., seven adult businesses

accounted for 36% of all crime in the area. In one case, a bar opened within 500 feet of

an SOB and serious crime within 1000 feet of that business rose 300% during the next

year.

♦ Phoenix, AZ -- 1978 - Sex offenses, including indecent exposure, were 506% greater in

neighborhoods with SOBs. Even excluding indecent exposure, the sex offenses were still

132% greater in those neighborhoods.

♦ Whittier, CA -- In comparison studies of two residential areas conducted between 1970-

1973 before SOBs, and 1974-1977 after SOBs, malicious mischief increased 700%,

assault increased 387%, prostitution increased 300%, and all theft increased 120%.

Virtually all SOBs, regardless of the city in which they are located, have similar negative

effects upon their surrounding neighborhoods. The Indianapolis study concluded that: Even a

relatively passive use such as an adult book store [has] a serious negative effect on [its]

immediate environs. It is difficult to miss the implication that these harmful secondary effects

simply reflect something harmful in the nature of the material.

Further, "high-frequency pornography consumers who were exposed to the nonviolent, dehumanizing pornography

(relative to those in the no-exposure condition) were particularly likely to report that they

might rape, were more sexually callous, and reported engaging in more acts of sexual

aggression. These effects were not apparent for men who reported a very low frequency

of habitual pornography consumption.The authors noted that the effects of exposure

were strongest and most pervasive in the case of exposure to nonviolent dehumanizing

pornography, the type of material that may in fact be most prevalent in mainstream

commercial entertainment videos.

The study found that more than twice as many men indicated at least some likelihood of

raping after exposure to this material 20.4 percent versus 9.6 percent. Detailed analysis

revealed that these effects occurred primarily for high P (psychotism) subjects those

who are inclined to be rather solitary and hostile, lack empathy, disregard danger and

prefer impersonal, non-caring sex (although not meeting clinical criteria as psychotics)."

A lot of data has been parsed more broadly on this subject and it doesn't bode well for the argument in favor of the proliferation of AI child pornography to combat real child exploitation, in spite of Aella's claim of "I Would Change My Mind If: ....We don’t actually have good data for most of this."

https://www.protectkids.com/effects/justharmlessfun.pdf

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 19, 2025
Comment removed
Friedrich Gerhard's avatar

The argument in the case of Denmark was that legalizing pornography resulted in sex crimes decreasing over the following years. However, rape and sexual assault increased. Ambiguously named "sex crimes" decreased overall because these minor crimes were decriminalized, so the total number of crimes was lower in the following years that the lesser crimes were decriminalized but the actual incidence of rape and sexual assault increased. Thus, "sex crimes" (now excluding peeping, voyeurism, and incest, yes, not violent crimes) went down but rape and sexual assault went up. I specifically stated violent sexual assaults and rapes to delineate those two categories I mentioned from the decidedly non-violent and lesser crimes that were decriminalized.

OldManFlappyNuts's avatar

You can probably literally debate her or have conversation with her on her channel. She’s very open

Lucia Alvarez's avatar

She also fails to recognize that an increasing chunk of CP viewers aren't even pedophiles by orientation. She's surveyed self-identifying pedophiles asking whether they think AI content would reduce their risk of offending - what she hasn't asked is "CP viewers, did you start out with a fixed pedophilic orientation, or did your tastes escalate?" She's too hasty to dismiss the very concept of sexual escalation when charged sex offenders (https://www.reddit.com/r/SexOffenderSupport/comments/1ev6t17/those_convicted_of_csam_charges_do_you_identify/?share_id=-EwCazAdF0qLUnQDVw3_h&utm_content=1&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1) and professionals who work with them (https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2020/dec/15/how-extreme-porn-has-become-a-gateway-drug-into-child-abuse) can vouch that it's no myth. There's a reason child protection and Internet watchdog organizations all oppose AI-CP. The more accessible such AI content becomes, the more it normalizes interest in the real thing and promotes the continued spread of real materials that should not continue to be spread, and even if few end up escalating to real-life contact offenses, that escalation in taste is itself a bad thing worth preventing.

Charlatan's avatar

"This is probably because men don’t watch rape porn very frequently, but they do watch infidelity / harem porn. Hence, they pursue what they see." You do see the flaw in your logic here? This is most likely a problem of reverse causation. It's more likely that it's not the case that we act out what we watch/see but that we watch/seek out what we are or already want. Hence, why comparatively few people watch rape porn, gay porn etc, and a majority of people watch straight people's porn.

Aella actually wrote a very good "Against Aella" piece, addressing a wider range of arguments against her original piece. It's good. And she mostly manages to weaken all of these strong counterarguments against her proposal except for the counterargument that CP will normalize child sexual exploitation and hence gives pedophiles an increasing boldness to act out their dangerous impulses. Her own counter-counterargument is also very good. I just don't find it convincing enough.

Aellaisapedophile's avatar

>Aella actually wrote a very good

I see the flaw. Were you at her gangbang? Maybe her disgusting germs got into your brain and now you're simping for a 120 IQ prostitute. Who knows.

Deuteronomy 14's avatar

It's probably even worse than your article implies since you have to account for the fact that sexual interest is not entirely innate and pornography itself shapes desires

L P's avatar

I’m sorry but I find this argument much more convincing and better researched

Leon Voß's avatar

Ok well this study shows that in 1989 when porn became less restricted, rapes increased and a decreasing trend on child sexual abuse softened before starting to go back up. https://sci-hub.se/10.1007/s10508-010-9696-y

The Denmark data is inconclusive and not fully relevant. It's been critiqued here: https://sci-hub.se/https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1468-2958.1995.tb00368.x

Importantly, most men don't watch rape porn, so rape rates have little to do with whether porn encourages men to seek out what they see in porn more. Rape could have fallen because porn made men seek out consensual relationships more thoroughly. It's not informative to my case.

The correlation between rigor and "convincing" to you is probably rather weak, since you seem biased and not very honest or intelligent. To claim this video is better researched than my article is strong evidence of that fact.

OldManFlappyNuts's avatar

It’s not rape porn, it’s porn in general decreases sexual assault incidents (see ‘male sedation hypothesis’)

After jerking off, you do not feel the need to indulge in whatever intrusive thoughts one may have. How is this not intuitive

Friedrich Gerhard's avatar

Yeah I am sure that someone who masturbates 4 times per day and doesn't have enough energy or motivation to go for a walk isn't going to be raping anyone but it isn't desirable for men to be in an addicted, unproductive and unhealthy state. Most porn users are not like this or can't be like this and we clearly see plenty of data demonstrating otherwise, as Bronski posted above and as have I, demonstrating that it isn't just sexual assault but many, many other negative and undesirable social outcomes.

https://www.protectkids.com/effects/justharmlessfun.pdf

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 19, 2025
Comment removed
Ackermann's avatar

All violent crime went down after 90s. Probably not related to porn.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 19, 2025
Comment deleted
Leon Voß's avatar

how do you know what is a crime of passion and what is premeditated? Murder tends to be premeditated. Rape less so.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 19, 2025
Comment removed
Leon Voß's avatar

There's no evidence this is causal

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 19, 2025
Comment removed
Leon Voß's avatar

You are a insanely overconfident and totally incorrect, I cited experiments. Your "natural experiment" (marketing term) is a broken IV model. Broadband access clearly will not effect rape only through porn. Better broadband leads to more time inside which simply lowers the chances of rape happening.